How-to
How to Hire Reliable Roofers: A Practical Guide
Quick Summary
To hire reliable roofers, check how long the business has traded, confirm it is registered, and ask for local references from recent similar jobs. Then ask for proof of public liability insurance before work starts and collect at least three written quotes to compare line by line.
- Ask for proof of public liability insurance and check the cover amount and expiry date.
- Request references from similar recent jobs and phone at least one of them.
- Get at least three written quotes and compare them line by line, not just by total.
- Walk away from cold callers, full upfront payment demands, and pressure to sign immediately.
Table of Contents
- Finding and Vetting Roofers: Questions to Ask a Roofer Before You Hire
- How to Check a Roofer's Credentials and Insurance
- What a Roofing Quote Should Include, and Signs of a Rogue Roofer
- Frequently Asked Questions
CJU Roofing Specialists has published this guide. For enquiries, visit cjuroofingspecialists.co.uk.
Last Updated: November 16, 2026
Finding and Vetting Roofers: Questions to Ask a Roofer Before You Hire
Hiring a reliable roofer starts before any work is agreed. Homeowners in Edinburgh, East Lothian and Midlothian often rush to hire reliable roofers after a storm, a short, careful check protects you from poor work and unfair bills.
Ask how long the business has traded, whether it is a registered company or sole trader, and for a local address. Request references from similar recent jobs and phone at least one.
Before you sign anything, ask these questions:
- Will you visit in person before quoting?
- Who supervises the work on site?
- How long will the job take?
- What workmanship guarantee do you give?
- Who do I contact if something goes wrong?
Watch out: pressure to sign on the spot, or a large payment upfront, is a serious warning sign.
Citizens Advice guidance on choosing a tradesperson
How to Check a Roofer's Credentials and Insurance
Ask every roofer for proof of public liability insurance before they start, as it protects you if someone is hurt or property is damaged. You can also compare roof replacement providers in the Lothians to see what guarantees and insurance to look for. Check the cover amount and expiry date.
Check trade memberships too: ask which recognised bodies they belong to, then confirm on the organisation's own website rather than a printed card.

If a roofer cannot show current insurance, do not hire them. To put your questions directly to a local team, contact CJU Roofing Specialists.
Health and Safety Executive guidance on working at height
What a Roofing Quote Should Include, and Signs of a Rogue Roofer
A good quote is written, detailed and easy to compare, listing scope of work, materials, labour, dates and payment terms. Vague lump-sum quotes make comparison difficult.
Get at least three written quotes and compare them line by line, not just by total cost, as a much lower price may mean cheaper materials or missing work when you hire reliable roofers. Use this checklist for reviewing roof repair quotes line by line before you accept any price.
Be alert to rogue roofer warning signs:
- Cold calls or unsolicited door-knocking after bad weather
- Full payment demanded before work starts
- No written contract, or one that changes after signing
- Reluctance to provide insurance or references
- Pressure to decide immediately
If you spot these signs, walk away. To get a quote or ask about our services, contact CJU Roofing Specialists today.
The article sets out what a good roofing quote should contain and the warning signs of a rogue roofer. For a closer look at transparency, read how to check a roof replacement quote before you sign.
| Item | What to look for | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Quote format | Written, detailed, easy to compare | Vague lump-sum quotes are hard to compare |
| Quotes to collect | At least three | Allows line-by-line comparison |
| Comparison basis | Line by line, not total cost | A much lower price may mean cheaper materials or missing work |
| Cold calls after bad weather | Unsolicited door-knocking | Warning sign of a rogue roofer |
| Payment demanded upfront | Full payment before work starts | Warning sign of a rogue roofer |
| Contract | Missing, or changes after signing | Warning sign of a rogue roofer |
| Insurance and references | Reluctance to provide them | Warning sign of a rogue roofer |
| Decision pressure | Demand to decide immediately | Warning sign of a rogue roofer |
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I find a reliable roofer?
Start with recommendations from neighbours, friends and family who have had roof work done recently, then check online reviews and ask for references from recent jobs similar to yours. Shortlist at least three roofers who have an in-person survey process, confirm they hold current public liability insurance, and check they have experience with your roof type, whether that is slate, tile or flat roofing. Reliable roofers will welcome these questions and answer them clearly in writing.
Should I get more than one roofing quote?
Yes. Getting at least three written quotes lets you compare the scope of work, materials, timelines and payment terms side by side. A quote that is much lower than the others often means something has been left out, such as underlay, flashing or waste removal. Make sure every quote is based on an in-person survey of your roof, so you are comparing like with like rather than estimates made from the pavement.
What are the warning signs of a rogue roofer?
Be cautious of anyone who asks for a large upfront payment, refuses to put the quote in writing, pressures you to sign on the same day, or offers a discount for paying in cash. Other red flags include no fixed business address, no insurance details, cold-calling after a storm without any local references, and claims that your roof needs urgent work without showing you the damage. A reputable roofer will explain the work clearly and give you time to decide.